Frat Trashes Rudolph’s House

East
Tuesday, February 17, 2009
.
Following a renovation by the fraternity that occupied it, all most all traces of Paul Rudolph have vanished from his New Haven home. (Calgary Leveen/Yale Daily News)

Following a renovation by the fraternity that occupied it, all most all traces of Paul Rudolph have vanished from his New Haven home. (Calgary Leveen/Yale Daily News)

One could make a living chronicling the iniquities visited upon the work of Paul Rudolph (lord knows we certainly have). From modest tract homes to cutting edge office towers, the trail-blazing, highly influential architect’s work has not fared well of late. Of the handful already demolished, as many are on the chopping block, and it has become an ongoing struggle for the Paul Rudolph Foundation to protect what’s left. One of the better projects to come along was the expansion of Rudolph’s Art & Architecture Building at Yale, where he taught for so long. But it now turns out that that was not the only renovation of the great architect’s work going on in New Haven.

ArchNewsNow pointed us to a story in yesterday’s Yale Daily News about the Sigma Phi Epsilon fraternity’s renovation to what was once Rudolph’s own New Haven home. According to the YDN, the fraternity spent $25,000 bringing the house up to code, while eliminating–inadvertently or not–many of Rudolph’s signature design features, such as his customary cantilevered stair case.

Matt Eisen ’10, the president of SigEp, said many elements of Rudolph’s original design had become safety hazards to the brothers living in the house and the students who flocked to the fraternity’s parties.

“I wish we could make it safe and retain architectural elements, but we had to take cautionary steps before an accident actually happened,” said Eisen, the executive editor for the News, noting that most of the fraternity’s brothers are probably not aware of the house’s significance.

[...]

The renovation project involved setting the stairs in sturdy steel frames with marble inserts, removing the fireplace and a platform on the ground floor — which Eisen described as “a tripping hazard that served no purpose,” — as well as stabilizing the balcony area that was nearly collapsing.

Bob Esposito, the property manager SigEp contracted for the project, reiterated that the main goal of the renovation was to upgrade the house to current design standards.

Building codes and architectural tastes have changed a lot since Rudolph’s time,” he said. “We wanted to make the house easier to maintain and more user friendly while keeping a great percentage of Rudolph’s original design intact.”

The Rudolph home, as it once was. As it was meant to be. (Courtesy Paul Rudolph Foundation)

The thing is, it remains unclear whether the building was actually unsafe, or simply unsafe to the greek brothers and sisters there-in. A glimpse of the pre-renovation building shows that it does not appear unsound, and perhaps only got that way after neglectful care. Indeed, in its own report on the story, the Paul Rudolph Foundation said that the house had been well cared for until recently, though the fraternity refused admittance to determine its most recent state prior to the renovation:

Through the various owners, and up until recently, many elements like the floating stairs were retained. A clearer example of which can be seen in Rudolph’s Halston Residence on 63rd Street for the famous Fashion magnate.

Much like his 23 Beekman Place residence which would follow (and he would intervene into and out of for 30 years), this house was a work in progress and always up for alteration and innovation.

Rudolph explicitly kept the 19th century Victorian exterior intact. (Bruce Barnes/Courtesy UMass Dartmouth)

Rudolph explicitly kept the 19th century Victorian exterior intact. (Bruce Barnes/Courtesy UMass Dartmouth)

That Rudolph primarily modified the buildings interior–there was a a rearyard addition–means that the latest renovations leave almost no traces of the original building, as the foundation notes. “The current look, all decked-out in Ikea, with “state-of-the-art” projection TV, as photographed by Calgary Leveen of the YDN is hardly recognizable as Rudolph’s one-time home and can no longer be realistically considered as ‘Rudolph space.’”

And now we are obliged to make a snide remark about the thuggish clumsiness of the debauched Yalies who could not help but fall down the elegant stairs at parties, and thus defiled a modernist masterpiece. Except that Rudolph accolate, Yalie, and architecture school dean Robert A.M. Stern, in speaking with the YDN, does it for us.

“The house was spectacular, innovative, glamorous,” said School of Architecture Dean Robert A.M. Stern ARC ’65. “It’s too bad they modified the cantilever steps, but it’s true that there are safety concerns without the railings, and at frat parties — it gets a bit lively, shall we say.”

14 Responses to “Frat Trashes Rudolph’s House”

  1. Doug Bartow says:

    >>simply tragic

    No, tragic is when someone breaks their neck falling off the original stairs.

    Form follows fracture?

  2. Sean Khorsandi says:

    Yes! The most unfortunate part of the story is the author wrote it at the behest of Mr. Eisen (her superior at the YDN) who basically countered anything the Foundation said.

    There have been attempts to discuss this project with the fraternity for over four years.

    In deference to what is written, the Foundation has NEVER been contacted by SigEp in regards to the High Street property.

    And the Foundation never endorsed the changes mentioned, when interviewed we commented that had Rudolph stayed in the house, he undoubtedly would have intervened further – (as he did, continuously to his main home at Beekman Place from 1967 until is death in 1997).

    The fully story will be published soon, and hopefully set the definitive record on yet another Rudolph demolition, and yet another loss for architecture as a discipline.

  3. rigamaziu says:

    If you’re like most people, you think that heart problems is a problem for other folks. But heart disease is the number one killer in the U.S. It is also a major cause of disability. There are many different forms of heart disease.

  4. Casino bonuses says:

    Good morning
    Where are You
    Rules for bar dice Play Rules for bar dice US Jackpot How to play dice casino How to play dice USA blackjack Role playing dice casino Role playing dice EURO Jackpot Big dice casino Big dice EURO Jackpot Virtual dice games Virtual dice UK poker Buy-Buy

  5. griesia says:

    so i just jailbroke my iphone (2g) and i got the cydia and installer. i heard theres alot of cool stuff you can do on it. like how do you function it? and how do you get custom sms tones.(i have window xp)??? helppp i wanna be on on the good stuff. lol ps. i already got keyboard colors and stuff from cydia. but its still idk what im doing. lol

    ________________
    unlock iphone 3g

  6. icoliCoth says:

    Hello. And Bye.

  7. GoneIntornfem says:

    фильм шайтан смотреть онлайн
    фильм ночной попутчик война невест фильм онлайн музыка из фильма мёртвый сезон фильм месть с кевином костнером смотреть фильм молодые папаши облако фильм торрент саундтрэк к фильму терминатор музыка из фильма вавилон мультфильм волшебники фильм безвозвратный путь смотреть онлайн белла из фильма сумерки фильмы ужасов 2009 я остаюсь фильм краско просмотр фильма джон кью скачать фильм экстази скачать бессплатно фильм голая правда песни из кинофильма держи ритм песни из фильма эффект бабочки фильм беовульф скачать фильм искусство войны 2 скачать фильм призраки в коннектикуте мультфильмы про роботов зорро мультфильм песня из фильма миллионер из трущоб порно фильм миранда фильм камилла онлайн самый лучший фильм 2 online скачать фильм титаник с letitbit фильм поезд смотреть онлайн смотреть фильм онлайн фаербол документальный фильм жизнь после людей онлайн фильм палач 1990 закрытый показ фильм русалка говорящая рыба мультфильм скачать онлайн фильм белая мгла немецкий фильм красавчик суперсемейка мультфильм скачать фильм схватка 1995 скачать фильм максимальный риск трейлер к фильму реальные девчонки бумер: фильм второй скачать фильм шанхайский полдень dvdrip эхо фильм скачать фильм мальчикам это нравится скачать фильм седьмая луна гвинет пэлтроу фильмография песни из фильма временно беременна фильм форсаж 4 худ фильм хроники мутантов фильм душа онлайн песни из фильма корабль призрак самые ожидаемые фильмы 2010 года фильм мой сводный брат франкенштейн супергеройский фильм смотреть мультфильм рики тики тави фильм фанат 2 саундтрек к фильму lol ржунимагу фильм стоик отзывы фильм слон скачать скачать фильм красный отель
    http://bobrdobr.ru/people/starter1987/

  8. shake says:

    Metin2 was developed in Korea and is based on a fascinating storyline. metin2 yang It leads you into an eastern fancy world. If you are fond of martial arts and want to become a master of it, this is the best game to you. There are many million online role playing gamers all around the world who take part in this adventure. The game is packed with great features including quests,metin2 yang guild battles and wars between nations.

  9. frendyfuk says:

    AgataNN.ru предлагает услуги по озеленению, ландшафтному строительству, благоустройству, отделки помещений и фасадов, строительству коттеджей, домов, бань.
    Специалисты фирмы обладают высокой квалификацией и огромным практическим опытом. Налаженная организация труда, предприимчивость, опыт решения сложных вопросов в ходе выполнения работ, умение находить неординарные решения для выполнения поставленных задач, опыт работы в данной сфере, постоянное обучение специалистов новым технологиям, наличие надежных постоянных партнеров – позволяет нам выполнять работы качественно и экономить ваше время и деньги.

  10. griesia says:

    Is there any way I can get the iPhone 3Gs for the regular price $199 without contract? Can I just go to the Apple store and buy the iPhone 3Gs and not activate it?

    ________________
    unlock iphone

  11. Gyggz says:

    Продукция, реализуемая нашим предприятием, пользуется авторитетом на рынке автозапчастей на рынке России, Татарстана, Туркменистана, Беларуси. Мы осуществляем поставку продукции в отдаленные и северные районы России. Результаты работы нашего предприятия вселяют уверенность, что наши Покупатели — автомобилисты и механизаторы, транспортники и судостроители — смогут приобрести необходимую им продукцию в нужном количестве, в удобное время, по приемлемым ценам. Мы, работники предприятия, исповедуя интересы Покупателей, говорим своим нынешним и будущим деловым партнерам: Давайте сотрудничать! Мы работаем для вас!

  12. agosotstohync says:

    Today i watching smokescreen from here.
    this is wondeful film.
    Who are watching this?

  13. James says:

    The important things about Rudolph’s work are the designs he created, which have been preserved photographically and will continue to be influential, rather than the physical structure itself. It’s too bad it has been altered, but safety should be the priority of course.

Advertise on The Architect's Newspaper.

Submit your competitions for online listing.

Submit your events to AN's online calendar.




Archives

Categories

Copyright © 2014 | The Architect's Newspaper, LLC | AN Blog Admin Log in. The Architect's Newspaper LLC, 21 Murray Street 5th Floor | New York, New York 10007 | tel. 212.966.0630
Creative Commons License
Pinterest