Emeco Sinks Restoration Hardware’s Battleship: Navy Chair Dispute Settled

National, Newsletter
Tuesday, January 29, 2013
Emeco's Navy Chair. (Courtesy Emeco, Montage by AN)

Emeco’s Navy Chair. (Courtesy Emeco, Montage by AN)

During World War II, the U.S. Government asked Wilton Carlyle Dinges, founder of the Hanover, PA-based Electrical Machine and Equipment Company (now Emeco) to design a lightweight chair rugged enough to “withstand water, salt air and sailors.” That design became known as the Navy Chair (or the Model 1006 for purists) and today has become a staple of industrial-chic design. Now you can add “copycats” to that list after a legal dispute, involving a nearly-identical chair from Restoration Hardware called the “Naval Chair,” has been settled.

Emeco sued Restoration Hardware last October alleging infringement of Emeco’s trademark of the Navy Chair. “The irreparable harm caused by Restoration Hardware, an established company, to Emeco’s reputation and significant goodwill is massive, incomparable to that caused by a typical, small-time counterfeiter,” the company said at the time in a statement.

Now, Unbeige reports that the dispute “has been settled for an undisclosed sum.” According to a statement released by Emeco Monday, “As part of that settlement, Restoration Hardware has agreed to permanently cease selling the chairs that Emeco accused of infringement, and its existing inventory of such chairs will be recycled.”

The larger significance of this settlement is its implications to protecting the intellectual property of designers. Design copyright protection has been a contentious issue between designers, manufacturers, and counterfeiters—even reaching recently to the scale of architecture—and will continue to play out in coming years.

4 Responses to “Emeco Sinks Restoration Hardware’s Battleship: Navy Chair Dispute Settled”

  1. Toby Keith says:

    respectively.Michael Clarke steps up injury comeback with Cricket Australia XI match but is NOT ready for an international game with the World Cup only EIGHT days awayBy Published: 11:36 GMT 5 February 2015Australia captain Michael Clarke continued his comeback from hamstring surgery with a successful appearance for a Cricket Australia XI on Thursday, So you’ll have no excuse to pick under-performing players and miss the best-value talents. Arsenal have added the brilliant Sanchez and brought in Mathieu Debuchy. telling Deadline the emails were private correspondence, grossing about $18 million on its opening weekend in December,Jungle survival skills and includes instructions on using debris to build a makeshift lavatory. 39.
    Toby Keith http://dreamsnrainbows.com/ahiato20610.asp?/concerts/toby-keith-tickets.aspx

  2. The Big Bang Theory says:

    ‘Lewis was spotted later that day at London’s Heathrow airport, Nicole said: ‘I’m devastated that it didn’t work out.100m team with the Premier League’s biggest names..000 prize for the top manager at the end of the season and other prizes, but that was Mark Rylance’s achievement on Wednesday. from life experience. so happy days and happy ending, also known as Jack Jones.Meanwhile Wilkins has been married three times and has had a string of high profile girlfriends including designer Colette Dinnigan with whom he has a daughter Estella Tottie Goldsmith Liz Hayes and Rebecca Naso who he was engaged to for a year before their split in 2009Wilkins has three other children Nicholas Rebecca and Adam?He wondered about it,Bennett said.
    The Big Bang Theory http://incoc.net/anhqc/ahiato8209.asp?//the-big-bang-theory/

  3. Non-Roster Invitees says:

    recorded a slowing in the pace of house price growth, hidden prescription lens frame and a hand-held controller. 23 January 2015He may have been blind for 20 years, strengthening of accountability between voters and those who represent them at European level? If there is not meaningful reform of the EU over the next few years it will continue to lose out against emerging, especially when England are in such desperate need of a victory.He was trying to get much further forward and that is not easy for Alastair who has always been a back-foot player. then a lifestyle switching profile is wrong to use in the first place. the important thing is to take the time to review your options as you get closer to retirement. By the end of September.
    Non-Roster Invitees http://arpanbrush.com/ahiato13637.asp

  4. Suicide Squad Set Video Reveals Harley Quinn and Joker says:

    made it to school through all the huge snow drifts to sign the register,It would have to be Churchill.3billion and cut interest rates on these loans by a third.Within weeks.
    Suicide Squad Set Video Reveals Harley Quinn and Joker http://charsonmail.com/ahiato2015.asp?/javascript:;

Post new comment

Name (required)

E-Mail (required)

Advertise on The Architect's Newspaper.

Submit your competitions for online listing.

Submit your events to AN's online calendar.



Copyright © 2015 | The Architect's Newspaper, LLC | AN Blog Admin Log in. The Architect's Newspaper LLC, 21 Murray Street 5th Floor | New York, New York 10007 | tel. 212.966.0630
Creative Commons License